Supply is beyond the course or furtherance of business

Supply is beyond the course or furtherance of business – AAR Karnataka

Since the advance ruling in case of M/s Rajashri Foods Private Limited has been announced by Authority of advance Ruling- Karnataka, we have been discussing that the transfer of business unit as a going concern shall be considered as supply of services which is exempt as per entry No. 2 of Notification No. 12/2017 dated 28.06.2017.

In the discussion we have forgot the most important dispute/argument this ruling has raised. As per Para 7.3.1 of the ruling, the authority held that Section 7 of the CGST Act 2017 is giving an inclusive definition of supply, which means that a transfer can still be treated as supply even if there is no consideration or it is made other than in the course or furtherance of business. Authority held that Transfer in course or furtherance of business is not an essential condition for considering it as a supply. This means that the supplies made on personal account which has no relation with the business shall also be treated as supply within the ambit of section 7 of the CGST Act 2017. Does this means that where a Chartered Accountant provides consultancy on personal account will also be treated as supply. Whether such supply is taxable or not is a separate question. The authority held that word “includes” has been used in section 7(1), the scope of supply goes beyond the meaning of the expression “in the course or furtherance of business”. Therefore in the case of the transfer of a going concern even if the act of transfer does not constitute an activity carried out in the course of regular business or for furtherance of business, the activity may still qualify to be termed as a supply.

If the law is interpreted in such manner, it is sure that GST is going to open up another pindora box of litigations and discussion over the question of law. The term supply itself shall be questioned at various instance, because going by this ruling- what is supply is not sufficiently defined and if the point of tax is itself questionable, then think about the disputes which are going to arise due to the biggest tax reform of the country.

Comments

GST Registration in case of Renting of Immovable properties:

GST Registration in case of Renting of Immovable properties: By CA. Keshav R Garg 1. Let us first understand that the place of registration is decided by the term place of business as defined by section 2(85) of the CGST Act 2017. As per the definition of “Place of Business” it is a place from where the business is carried on and/or where a warehouse or any other place for storage of goods is located and/or books of accounts are maintained and/or the business through agent is carried on. It nowhere considers “place of supply” for determining the Place of business for the purpose of GST Registration. Hence, place of supply has no impact as far as GST Registration is concerned. 2. As per section 22 of the CGST Act 2017, a person is liable to take registration from the place he makes a taxable supply. There is a distinction in place of supply and place from one makes taxable supplies. Place of supply is derived to conclud...

Renting of Warehouse for Agriculture Produce – Taxable under GST

In the case of Rishi Shipping – Gujarat Authority for Advance Ruling has cleared the air that Storing/warehousing and renting of immovable property are two different type of services. Merely because the agricultural produce is stored in an immovable property it would not classify it as Storage and Warehousing Services. Therefore the same shall not be covered under S. No. 54 of Negative List (Notification No. 12/2017- Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017), hence taxable under the purview of CGST and IGST Act. The Authority held that in order to classify a service as Storage and Warehousing, it should be coupled with loading/unloading/packing services etc. The authority was of the view that where mere building is let out, it shall be classified as renting of immovable property which is chargeable to tax. It is the composite supply, principal supply being renting of immovable property for storage of agricultural produce which is exempt from tax. It further held that once the...

Practical examples and solutions to understand applicability of reduced interest under GST - [CA. Keshav R Garg]

Practical examples and solutions to understand applicability of reduced interest under GST [CA. Keshav R Garg] There has been whole lot of discussions about how the applicability of reduced rate of interest and waiver of late fees shall work in case of taxpayers having turnover exceeding Rs. 5 crores. The Notification Nos 31/2020, 32/2020 and 33/2020 – Central Tax dated 03.04.2020 provides for lower interest, waive of late fees for GSTR 3B and waiver for late fees of GSTR 1 respectively. There had been various documents where these notifications has been misinterpreted and industry is assuming that due dates of filing of returns have been extended. It is not the due dates of the returns which have been extended rather late fees applicable on them has been waived off with a condition that if the returns are not filed as per dates specified by the government full late fees and interest shall be made applicable. We shall understand the complete issue by way of practical...

Goods and Services Tax

Search This Blog